Highest Rated Comments
nortern19 karma
The journal has all it needs at this point, as does IOP, and I'm not going to do everyone's work for them for free
Let me translate that.
I enjoy hurling accusations, but I don't think my argument can actually pass peer review to be published as a letter or an errata.
There is a process to let authors address serious concerns in publication. The fact that he does not want to use that avenue to formally air his issues with the scientific community is suspect.
nortern167 karma
Do you think it's possible they removed power on purpose as part of the study?
edit: spelling
View HistoryShare Link